The case of the stolen gift

White Elephant Gifts People Will Actually Fight Over

In a white elephant swap, the goal isn't the perfect gift for one person. It's the gift the whole room wants to steal.

The winners are funny but useful, with something to do inside the box. Skip the novelty junk that ends up in a drawer. These eight get stolen.

Gift Detective may earn a commission from links on this page. Prices change, so check the store for the current price.

  1. Exhibit 01 Under $25 · Amazon

    Throw Throw Burrito Card Game

    A card game where you throw squishy burritos at each other. It usually gets played on the spot.

    See it at Amazon
  2. Exhibit 02 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Shiitake Mushroom Log Kit

    Grow your own mushrooms on a log. Strange enough to get a laugh, cool enough to steal.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  3. Exhibit 03 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Make Your Own Hot Sauce Kit

    A make-your-own hot sauce kit. Everybody wants to be the one who brews the heat.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  4. Exhibit 04 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Cocktail Garden Starter Grow Kit

    Grows the garnishes for cocktails. Funny, useful and a reliable steal.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  5. Exhibit 05 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    DIY Edible Butter Candle Kit

    A candle made of butter that they can eat. It needs to be explained, which is half the fun.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  6. Exhibit 06 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Murder Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle

    Finish the jigsaw, then use it to solve a murder. A puzzle with a twist.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  7. Exhibit 07 Under $25 · Amazon

    Exploding Kittens Card Game

    The card game with exploding kittens. Silly, fast and great for groups.

    See it at Amazon
  8. Exhibit 08 Under $25 · Uncommon Goods

    Fitness Dice

    Dice that choose the workout. The person who opens it will laugh, then maybe use it.

    See it at Uncommon Goods

How to crack this case

  • Aim for funny and useful. Gag gifts that serve no purpose get stolen once and then forgotten.
  • Gifts you can open and use on the spot, like games, create the most excitement.
  • Wrap it well. In a white elephant swap, the wrapping is part of the performance.

Still stumped?

Let the quiz do the detective work.

Answer 7 quick questions and get six gifts matched to your person and your budget.

Open a new case

More gift guides