The classic cold case

Gifts for Someone Who Has Everything

They bought the gadget before you heard of it, and their kitchen drawer is fully stocked. When someone already has everything, another object usually ends up in a closet.

The fix is to stop shopping for things and start shopping for moments. Look for gifts they'll use up, gifts that give them something new to do, or a better version of something they reach for every day. Here are eight that pass the test.

Gift Detective may earn a commission from links on this page. Prices change, so check the store for the current price.

  1. Exhibit 01 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Coffee From Around the World Gift Set

    Nine coffees to taste and then finish. It's a small adventure that leaves nothing behind but an empty box.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  2. Exhibit 02 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Shiitake Mushroom Log Kit

    Even people who have everything don't usually own a mushroom farm. It gives them something to tend and then something to cook.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  3. Exhibit 03 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    The FairyTale Files Interactive Murder Mysteries

    A night of solving a mystery with friends counts as a whole evening, not another item on a shelf.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  4. Exhibit 04 $50–100 · Uncommon Goods

    Chocolate & Coffee Tasting Class

    A guided tasting turns one evening into an experience. It's ideal for someone whose shelves are already full.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  5. Exhibit 05 $50–100 · Amazon

    Hotel-Quality Cotton Bath Towel Set

    They have towels, but probably not hotel-quality ones. Upgrading something they use every day is a quiet win.

    See it at Amazon
  6. Exhibit 06 $100–200 · Amazon

    Aura Digital Picture Frame (10-inch)

    A frame that fills itself with new family photos. It's practical and sentimental at once, and it keeps getting better.

    See it at Amazon
  7. Exhibit 07 $100–200 · Uncommon Goods

    Ultimate S'mores Kit

    S'mores indoors, with everything included. It's a treat they would never think to buy for themselves.

    See it at Uncommon Goods
  8. Exhibit 08 $25–50 · Uncommon Goods

    Personalized National Parks Scratch Off Poster

    For the well-traveled: a poster that turns past trips into a running scoreboard and future trips into a plan.

    See it at Uncommon Goods

How to crack this case

  • Pick something they'll use up or do, rather than keep. Food, drink and activity kits never add clutter.
  • Upgrade an everyday item. The things people use daily are the things they rarely replace for themselves.
  • Ask a co-conspirator. A partner or close friend often knows the one thing they've been eyeing.

Still stumped?

Let the quiz do the detective work.

Answer 7 quick questions and get six gifts matched to your person and your budget.

Open a new case

More gift guides